In the original book, one pilot reported that while flying at 5,000 feet on a bombing run he saw, because of the fierce burning of dresden, a freight car shoot past his plane. Critics say that the military value of the bombing did not justify dresdens near destruction and that the city could have been spared, like rome, paris, and kyoto. Feb, 2017 british world war ii veteran victor gregg might not be alive today were it not for the allied bombardment of dresden. British soldier and pow victor greggs eyewitness account of the dresden bombings in february 1945. The subject of the book, the bombing of germany, 194045 was deftly analyzed by the author. Feb 12, 2020 david irving would claim in his 1963 book, the destruction of dresden, that the bombing was the biggest single massacre in european history. During the extensive bombing of dresden by the allies, german guards hide. Apr 01, 2015 in the dresden bombings an estimated total of 3,900 tons of explosives were utilized for the destruction of the aforementioned military structures. A tearful veteran who witnessed the dresden bombing today recalled the moment he saw children melting in the firestorm. The text centers on billys capture by the german army and his survival of the allied firebombing of dresden. A brief respite ensued after these february bombings, but on march 2, the u. Victor gregg says the events left him psychologically. Though checked at the battle of the bulge in the west and with the soviets pressing hard on the eastern front, the third reich continued to mount a stubborn defense. Perhaps the most rewarding of the many books written about the dresden bombing.
The britishamerican bombing of dresden took place between february 15, 1945 during the final months of world war ii. Feb 14, 2015 a harrowing eye witness account of the firebombing of dresden by former pow victor gregg. It reopened the moral investigation into the dresden bombings, and by implication, war in general. The bombing was controversial because dresdena historic city. The destruction of dresden is a 1963 nonfiction book which describes the february 1945 bombing of dresden in world war ii. The one slight criticism i have is that, with so many individuals mentioned, it was a bit difficult to get an in depth feeling for any one individual. All this happened, more or less, is how vonnegut introduces the novel. Historians all agree that a large number of german refugees were in dresden during the night of february 14, 1945. However, the estimate of refugees in dresden that night varies widely. By the beginning of 1945, german fortunes looked bleak.
Feb 06, 2004 michael burleigh is won over by dresden, frederick taylors staunch defence of the bombing raid condemned by others as a war crime michael burleigh fri 6 feb 2004 20. Aftermath from february to february 15, 1945, during the final months of world war ii 193945, allied forces bombed the historic city of dresden, located in eastern germany. There are suggestions below for improving the article. How many germans died under raf bombs at dresden in 1945. After the firestorm debating the dresden death toll wears.
Frederick taylors wellresearched and unpretentious book is a robust defence of the dresden raids that counters recent attempts to recast the nation that gave the world auschwitz as the second. Vonnegut doesnt describe the dresden bombing at the center of the novel. Great book that painted a stunning image of the human suffering involved in the bombing of dresden and also raised moral questions about just what constitutes an acceptable target in a war. The book is rich in character development, and set against the horrible events of the second great war, may leave readers wanting to know more about the events that are discussed in the book. The bombs created a huge fire that destroyed every. At the end of world war ii the city of dresden was in ruins, all its buildings destroyed and thousands of civilians dead. New book examines the bombing of dresden a tale of. A gripping work of narrative nonfiction recounting the hi. An eyewitness account by edda west my grandmother would always begin the story of dresden by describing the clusters of red candle flares dropped by the first bombers, which like hundreds of christmas trees, lit up the night sky a sure sign it would be a big air raid.
Feb 16, 2006 the original book dresden written prior to the mid 1960s told the truth without any revision of history or facts. Dresden, a city unaffected by bombing up to that point in the war, lost many thousands of civilians in the firestorm that was created by the allies. See more ideas about dresden, dresden bombing and wwii. Once these issues have been addressed, the article can be renominated. The bombing of the german city of dresden by the allies was one of the most controversial events of world war ii. A dutydance with death 1969, which is a satirical novel about world war ii experiences and journeys through time of a soldier named billy pilgrim.
The destruction of dresden, was easily the most influential book in creating the continually high level of controversy, outrage, and misinformation regarding the bombings. The history and legacy of the allies most controversial attack on germany. Tearful veteran who witnessed dresden bombing recalls. Tuesday, february, 1945 that dresden had been accepting refugees from the devastated cities of the ruhr, and from hamburg and berlin, ever since the british bombing campaign began in earnest.
The bombing of dresden in february 1945 has remained one of the more controversial aspects of world war two. Raf heavy bombers are seen dropping bombs over dresden, germany toward the end of world war ii in this remarkable archive footage from 1945. A survivors story, february 1945 reprint by victor gregg isbn. Given the high number of civilian casualties and the relatively few strategic targets, some even called the bombing of dresden a war. Bombing of dresden in world war ii was a warfare good articles nominee, but did not meet the good article criteria at the time. Vonneguts use of the firebombing of dresden as a central event makes the novel semi.
In his book dresden, mckay has made good use of the oral history archive available in the city to reconstruct the personal stories of survivors. Whats the best historynonfiction book on the bombing of. David irving would claim in his 1963 book, the destruction of dresden, that the bombing was the biggest single massacre in european history. The destruction of dresden, the florence on the elbe, by british and american bombers in february 1945 was one of the most controversial. But the now97 year old finds it difficult to reconcile the hellish events of february, 1945 with victory. The bombing of dresden was a historic benchmark that demonstrated the power of strategic bombing. In the last months of world war ii, allied bombers conducted several major bombing raids on the eastern german city of dresden. A survivor recalls the horror he witnessed in the german city.
Rifleman victor gregg recalls the firestorm left behind when allies attacked the city in 1945. During world war ii, at the age of 23, he was captured by the germans and imprisoned beneath the city of dresden. It follows the life and experiences of billy pilgrim, from his early years to his time as an american soldier and chaplains assistant during world war ii, to the postwar years, with billy occasionally traveling through time itself. There have been many books on the bombing of dresden. The scale of the death and destruction, coming so late in the war, along with significant questions about the legitimacy of the targets destroyed have led to years of. Feb 15, 20 i survived the bombing of dresden and continue to believe it was a war crime this article is more than 7 years old. I survived the bombing of dresden and continue to believe. From february to february 15, 1945, during the final months of world war ii 193945, allied forces bombed the historic city of dresden, located in eastern germany. Sep 07, 2017 frederick taylor states in his book dresden. Memory and the politics of commemorating destruction, to be launched on thursday, april 2, dr joel tracks the way the story around the bombing of dresden has been written, rewritten and appropriated since 1945. In four raids between and 15 february 1945, 722 heavy bombers of the british royal air force raf and 527 of the united states army air forces usaaf dropped more than 3,900 tons of highexplosive bombs.
The bombing of dresden, 1945 sinclair mckays the fire and darkness is an odd sort of book as it documents the firebombing of dresden on february,14 of 1945. The book, issued first in 1963, placed the death toll at least 5,000. The bombs created a huge fire that destroyed every building in the city and killed around 25,000 civilians. The book is based on a series of 37 articles written on the strategic bombing during world war ii by david irving called wie deutschlands stadte starben english. In four raids between and 15 february 1945, 722 heavy bombers of the british royal air force raf and 527 of the united states army air forces usaaf dropped more than 3,900 tons of highexplosive bombs and incendiary devices on the city. In the dresden bombings an estimated total of 3,900 tons of explosives were utilized for the destruction of the aforementioned military structures. Dresden bombings dresden bombing facts dk find out. Michael burleigh is won over by dresden, frederick taylors staunch defence of the bombing raid condemned by others as a war crime michael burleigh fri 6 feb 2004 20.
Sep 07, 2017 population of dresden during allied bombings. By late 1943 dresden was already overstretched and finding it hard to accept more outsiders. The original book dresden written prior to the mid 1960s told the truth without any revision of history or facts. Feb, 2019 a tearful veteran who witnessed the dresden bombing today recalled the moment he saw children melting in the firestorm. Jul 15, 2014 dresden in ruins after allied bombings, february 1945.
Slaughterhousefive was read widely as a graphic statement on the futility of war, capturing the zeitgeist of the time, when antivietnam war protests were at their zenith. Feb, 2020 still, steinmeier said those who perished in the dresden bombings deserved to be commemorated, just like those killed by nazi germanys aerial bombings in guernica, coventry, naples, le havre and. How germanys cities died for the german journal neue illustrierte. Yes dresden was a awful event and strategic bombing was the worst thing the allies ever did after the nuclear bomb but comparing it the industrial killing of twelve million jews, political prisoners, slavs, roma, homosexuals, freemasons, serbs and slovenes is. This site is to serve as a gateway for students who are interested in locating multiple materials regarding zusaks. I survived the bombing of dresden and continue to believe it was a war crime this article is more than 7 years old. Author provided a complete and reasonably impartial overview of the bombing of germany during ww ii. The us bombing raid on dresden took place on valentines day. Understanding the bombing of dresden book summaries, test. Finally, the destruction of dresden concluded with the 8th air force sending 572 bombers over the city on april 17. Not specifically about just dresden but a great piece on the bombings of german cities and why authors and people in germany in general didnt talk much about it. Editors may also seek a reassessment of the decision if they believe there was a mistake. Slaughterhousefive, or the childrens crusade the new york. Learn facts for kids about the dresden bombings in world war ii and find out more with dk find out.
After the firestorm debating the dresden death toll. Vonnegut has said that this death is the climax of the book as a whole. German president marks dresden bombing, warns of rising hate. The bombing was controversial because dresden was neither important to german wartime production nor a major industrial center. The book uses the public commemoration of the citys wartime destruction as a case study to. Dresden was bombed on the evening of february th and into february 14th. This book was released for the 75th anniversary of the dresden bombing raids of 1945.
A dutydance with death is a science fictioninfused antiwar novel by kurt vonnegut, first published in 1969. Beginning on the night of february, 1945, more than 1,200 heavy. Tuesday february 1945, the guardian 7th february, 2004. Was the bombing of dresden legitimate or a war crime. British soldier and pow victor greggs eyewitness account of the dresden bombings in february 1945 about the author victor gregg was born in london in 1919 and joined the army in 1937, serving first in the rifle brigade in palestine and north africa, notably at the battle of alamein, and then with the parachute regiment, at the battle of arnhem. Dorling kindersley, dk, eyewitness and the open book logo are trade marks of dorling kindersley limited. A harrowing eye witness account of the firebombing of dresden by former pow victor gregg. Soldier victor gregg, 99, had been sentenced to death after being taken pris. First, if the reader expects the storyline to read as does the formulaic but comprehensive works of martin middlebrook, the reader might be disappointed. I survived the bombing of dresden and continue to believe it. The bombing of dresden was a britishamerican aerial bombing attack on the city of dresden, the capital of the german state of saxony, during world war ii. German president marks dresden bombing, warns of rising. As a prisoner of war held in dresden, i still suffer the memories.
Apr, 2014 raf heavy bombers are seen dropping bombs over dresden, germany toward the end of world war ii in this remarkable archive footage from 1945. Markus zusaks the book thief is a beautifully written book set in world war ii germany. Bombing of dresden in world war ii military wiki fandom. This is a major reason for the discrepancies in the death toll estimates in the dresden bombings. Vonneguts point was to use the dead of dresden as a spectral presence who inform the living about the atrocities of all war, with the point being that every collateral victim is one too many, writes rigney. As the russians advanced to berlin from the east and the allies from the west, why was dresden bombed when it did appear that the war. Instead he writes around it in a highly imaginative, often funny, nearly psychedelic story.
115 1437 514 286 248 459 764 931 1343 1114 6 232 666 284 1054 755 86 1421 238 1093 394 1473 838 392 26 770 1168 555 1056 891 275 1386 1159 1231 463